Reader Discussion: Rock Band Or Guitar Hero?

We asked this question back in April, but now that both are out in the wild we're asking it again – Rock Band 4 or Guitar Hero Live?

We've reviewed both games. You can find our review of Rock Band 4 here and our review of Guitar Hero Live here. Rock Band 4 is more focused on creating the classic Rock Band 4 experience for a new generation, while Guitar Hero Live is trying something a little different. Do you have a preference now that you've had a chance to check out both? Or maybe you committed to one without trying both out first? Or maybe you're done with plastic instrument rock music games.

Let us know in the comments below.