We're Back. We hope you'll join us. Learn more

Review

Beyond: Two Souls Review

A Flawed Epic
by Matt Helgeson on Oct 08, 2013 at 05:00 AM
Reviewed on PlayStation 3
Also on PlayStation 4, PC
Publisher Sony Computer Entertainment
Developer Quantic Dream
Release
Rating Mature

I think of David Cage as an auteur, a distinction that would no doubt please him. His studio, Quantic Dream, makes games unlike any other in the industry, doubling down on quicktime button-press events and advanced graphics technology to create digital stories that are at once startlingly lifelike and completely surreal. He’s nothing if not distinctive.

Cage fancies that he’s bringing true emotion into games, and – to an extent – he’s right. His bizarre serial-killer noir Heavy Rain was weighted down with themes of parental love and loss. These carry over to Beyond: Two Souls, a game that tells the convoluted tale of Jodie, a girl linked to the afterworld through her connection to an omniscient dead soul named Aiden.

In a story told through out-of-sequence chapters, we see Jodie grow from a small child with mysterious powers to a lonely teen adopted and held captive by researcher Nathan Hawkins (played by Willem Dafoe). Later, she puts her abilities to use as a CIA operative.

Though I like his work, it’s worth noting that Cage, for all his cinematic ambitions, isn’t much of a writer. He just doesn’t have a feel for realistic dialogue; conversations often come off stilted and awkward. He also has a flair for melodrama that lends his games an artificial, overwrought quality. However, it’s less of an issue in Beyond, due to excellent performances by Page, Dafoe, and former A Different World star Kadeem Hardison. They are seasoned actors, and it shows. Page isn’t afraid to underplay a scene – a virtue in a game as overblown as Beyond.

Sorry, this video is not available

7.75
Concept
David Cage uses his story-driven design formula to tell the tale of a girl with strange occult powers
Graphics
The facial animation is unparalleled. Star Ellen Page looks remarkably lifelike
Sound
The voice cast, anchored by Page and Willem Dafoe, delivers a vast improvement over the awkward line readings of Heavy Rain
Playability
I like the changes to the quicktime event mechanics, but Beyond struggles when it attempts to ape conventional action games
Entertainment
Fascinating and frustrating, this game doesn’t always play to Quantic Dream’s strengths. Still, it holds many genuinely affecting moments
Replay
Moderately High

Products In This Article

Beyond: Two Soulscover

Beyond: Two Souls

Platform:
PlayStation 4, PlayStation 3, PC
Release Date:
October 8, 2013 (PlayStation 3), 
November 24, 2015 (PlayStation 4), 
June 22, 2019 (PC)